University of Florida Gators — Courtesy: Shutterstock — Gregory Reed
Growing up in Gainesville, Jack O’Keefe was surrounded by the legacy of the Florida Gators. As a fifth-year senior at UF, he had long awaited his defining moment—one that would join the ranks of the unforgettable.
Where were you when Chris Chiozza stunned Wisconsin? When Ahmad Black took down Oklahoma? When Danny Wuerffel crushed Tennessee with 48 unanswered points?
On Saturday night, O’Keefe finally got his moment: Where were you when Walter Clayton Jr. propelled Florida basketball into the Final Four?
A Night of Anticipation and Emotion
O’Keefe, along with hundreds of passionate Gators fans, watched history unfold at MacDinton’s Irish Pub, formerly known as Social at Midtown. The energy in the air was electric, the kind of buzz that only a major victory can generate.
Midtown had transformed into a sea of orange and blue, with fans eager to witness history. Bars capitalized on the excitement—MacDinton’s charged a steep $40 entry fee, yet students paid without hesitation. After all, moments like these had been scarce. A senior at UF has only seen one winning football season and no NCAA Tournament victories. While baseball and softball have thrived, those championships unfold in the summer, when most students have left town.
From NW 13th Street to 3rd Ave, Gator Nation held its breath as the game began. The first half saw Florida grind out a three-point lead, bringing confidence that they could pull away as they did against Maryland just days before.
Doubt Creeps In
That confidence wavered as Texas Tech proved to be a much tougher opponent. The Red Raiders seized control, stretching their lead to nine with just three minutes remaining. The once-boisterous crowd at MacDinton’s grew uneasy. Frustration mounted over missed calls and lost rebounds, and resignation began to set in.
Yet, O’Keefe refused to give up hope.
“With these types of players, there’s always a chance,” he said. “We’re the kind of team that can go on a run, hit a couple of big shots, and turn the game around.”
As tension filled the air, the Gators found their spark.
A Comeback for the Ages
Momentum shifted when Thomas Haugh drained a crucial three-pointer—then another. The once-muted crowd roared back to life. When Clayton tied the game, excitement rippled through Midtown. Then came the defining moment: Clayton, bypassing an easy layup, stepped back and sank a go-ahead three-pointer that sent the bar into a frenzy.
The final moments played out in slow motion. Darrion Williams missed critical shots, while Alijah Martin’s clutch free throws sealed the win. Then, as Alex Condon intercepted the final inbounds pass, the realization set in: Florida was heading to the Final Four.
The celebration erupted. Beer flowed, strangers embraced, and tears of joy streamed down faces. The game’s audio cut out as the crowd erupted in “Go Gators” chants. Then came Tom Petty’s Won’t Back Down, a Gainesville anthem that amplified the moment.
“I’ve never heard a bar this loud in Gainesville,” O’Keefe admitted. “It was so intense it almost felt silent.”
The Road Ahead
Trent Phillips, who attended UF’s last Final Four appearance in 2014, recalled the heartbreak of losing to UConn. This time, he believes experience will make the difference.
“These guys have been here before,” Phillips said. “A-Mart has Final Four experience, and Walt has played for years. Depth matters in March. When you have guys coming off the bench making an impact, that’s how you make a deep run.”
As fans trickled out of MacDinton’s, some made their way to The Swamp—a Gainesville staple rich with history. Walls adorned with memorabilia from past championship teams stood as a reminder of UF’s greatness.
Will another piece of history be added in eight days? Gator Nation will find out in San Antonio.
Stories that matter are our priority. At Florida Insider, we make sure that the information we provide our readers is accurate, easy-to-read, and informative. Whether you are interested in business, education, government, history, sports, real estate, nature or travel: we have something for everyone. Follow along for the best stories in the Sunshine State.
Melissa’s career in writing started more than 20 years ago. Today, she lives in South Florida with her husband and two boys.
